Can a Monarch Butterfly Fly Across the Atlantic Ocean?

Thinking Like a Scientist
As your students pose their own ideas about this puzzle — and look at fifth graders' theories — they will begin to think like scientists. Remind them that scientists are not even sure of the answer!

Once they've pondered how the monarchs may have gotten there, invite them to look at the facts and state the case for one of the theories. Here are some suggestions:

  • Before having students review the Look at the Facts page, pass out the Weigh the Evidence handout.
  • To simplify, you can have the class vote on one theory, and read the facts with that in mind. (Or you could have small groups each consider one theory.)
  • To simplify, you can also select and have students ponder just a few facts from the list.
  • Once students have found evidence to support or refute theories, have a classroom debate! Small groups can "state the case" for different theories.
  • Report your ideas to us; we'd love to hear your thoughts! Contact Journey North >>
  • If you have older students, share this example of how one scientist layed out an argument to defend his theory. >>

Copyright 2006 Journey North. All Rights Reserved.
Please send all questions, comments, and suggestions to
our feedback form.