Jim Gilbert
Monarch 
Butterfly

Today's News
Today's News

Spring's Journey North
Spring's Journey North
Report Your Sightings
Report Your Sightings
Teacher's Manual
Teacher's Manual
Search Journey North
Search Journey North
return to:
JNorth Home Page

A/CPB Home A/CPB

Challenge Question #8

Paul Cherubini (paulcher@concentric.net)
Mon, 06 Apr 1998 19:25:34 +0000

My experience has been that approximately 20-30 minutes after sunset,
monarch butterflies will not fly no matter how warm and calm field
conditions may be.

If, on a warm, calm, full moonlit night, the butterflies are shaken from
a roost or tossed into the air the butterflies soon crash into into
nearby objects or the ground - they do not seem to be physically capable
of "seeing" and maintaining oriented flight back to nearby trees.

Therefore, I am highly skeptical of the concept that monarch butterflies
might be capable of remaining air borne at night and in this way,
possibly cross the Atlantic ocean or Gulf of Mexico. I believe
trans-oceanic journeys are possible only if the butterflies are lucky
enough to find and stay with a ship, or hotscotch from one oil drilling
platform (or land island) to another. Keeping up with a ship is actually
more difficult for the butterflies than it might sound because modern
ships move at roughly 20-30 mph and this creates gusty, turbulent winds
on the deck.

Paul Cherubini
paulcher@concentric.net